Review: EnjoyGadgets 3 Port HDMI Switch

Friday, May 14th, 2010 at 11:13

1. Introduction

With Avatar’s Blu-Ray discs having sold 2.6 million copies in the first two days, it appears that we have been in the HD era longer than we thought —- so long that some of the HDTV’s early adopters find themselves in a slightly awkward position today, as there are so many HD devices to be plugged in, yet so few HDMI ports on their HDTVs for these many devices.

Early HDTVs tend to have just about 1 or 2 HDMI ports, maybe because there used to be not that many HDMI devices around in the market.

In order to connect your many HDMI devices to your HDTV, one way, of course, is to upgrade to a new HDTV which nowadays usually has 4 or more HDMI ports, but that also results in significantly lighter weight of your wallet.

A more economic way is to use an HDMI switch.

If you have many HDMI devices that you want to hook up to your HDTV, but your HDTV has only 1 or 2 HDMI ports, this article will give some in-depth information on a 3 Port HDMI switch.

2. What is an HDMI switch (HDMI switcher, HDMI selector), and what does it do?

An HDMI switch (also known as HDMI switcher, HDMI selector) receives HDMI signals from multiple HDMI sources and sends the signals from one of them to your HDTV. This way, it serves as an agent to accept many HDMI signals for your HDTV, even if your HDTV has only 1 or 2 HDMI port(s).

HDMI Switch

You can connect multiple HD sources to your HDTV, such as your:

  • Blu-Ray player, HD-DVD player, DVD player with HDMI output;
  • PS3, Xbox360, Wii with HDMI output;
  • HTPC, or computers with HDMI ports;
  • HDTV box, satellite dish network, HDTV recorder;
  • HD camera, or HD Cam recorder;
  • Any other devices that are capable of outputting HDMI signals.

HDMI Switch demo

People have come up with all kinds of creative names for HDMI switches. The most common names are HDMI switch, HDMI switcher and HDMI selector; however, it is also popularly known as an HDMI hub, HDMI adapter, HDMI switchbox, sometimes even HDMI splitter (although HDMI splitter receives one signal and outputs to more than one HDTVs), or any combination of these words.

3. Appearance and Design

Let’s take a closer look at the HDMI switch.

It has 4 ports on its sides, 3 input ports receiving signals from HDMI sources, and 1 output port sending signals to the HDTV. There is a red LED light on each input side to indicate which source is selected.

It has a “Select” button on its top surface. This button is for manual switching of the HDMI inputs, which we will cover soon in the following Automatic and Manual HDMI Switching section.

4. Specifications

The following table summarizes its technical details.

Input / Output
Video FullHD, 1080p, 1920×1080p
Audio LPCM, DTS/DTS-HD, Dolby Digital/Dolby TrueHD
HDMI Compliance HDMI v1.3b
HDCP Compliance HDCP v1.0/1.1 pass-through
Input DDC Signal 5 volts p-p (TTL)
HDMI Connector Type-A 19pin Female (common)
No. of HDMI Input 3
No. of HDMI output 1
Resolution
Progressive 1080p, 720p, 576p, 480p
Interlaced 1080i, 576i, 480i
Environment
Frequency 60Hz / 50Hz
Amplifier Bandwidth 2.5Gbps / 250 Mhz
Operating Temperature 0 ~ 70°C (32 ~ 158°F)
Storage Temperature -10 ~ 80°C (14 ~ 176°F)
Operating Humidity 10 ~ 85% RH
Storage Humidity 5 ~ 90% RH
External Power Supply None
Max Power 5W
Physical Demension
Size 51 x 52 x 14 mm (2 x 2.1 x 0.6 inch)
Weight 28g (0.1lb)
Warranty
EnjoyGadgets 1-year limited

Some of the highlights include support for:

  • 3 HDMI inputs and 1 output;
  • 1080p (FullHD), 1080i, 720p resolutions;
  • LPCM, DTS/DTS-HD, Dolby Digital/Dolby TrueHD audio formats;
  • HDMI v1.3b compliant (common);
  • HDCP v1.0/v1.1 pass-through (common);

It supports all HD and SD resolutions, and all the audio formats supported by Blu-Ray standards.

It supports up to 3 HDMI inputs. For many users, 3 ports are enough for their needs. Some users may need to connect to 4 or more HD sources. Although this particular HDMI switch does not fit their needs, there are also 4 port, 5 port or 8-port HDMI switches, which usually have higher price tags.

Is HDMI v1.3b good enough?

The short answer is yes, because 99% of the products out there in the market are compliant with HDMI 1.3b or earlier standards, such as HD-DVD players, PS3, Xbox360 and most Blu-Ray players.

Although HDMI v1.4 (released in May 2009) does bring in some features such as 3D Over HDMI and resolutions up to 4k x 2k, there are very few products or cables supporting this new standard. Because of this, we did not know of any HDMI switches in the market that support HDMI 1.4 yet, although it should be a matter of time for the switches to adopt HDMI 1.4 as well in the future.

HDCP in HDMI Switches

HDCP is a copy protection to prevent copy-righted contents from traveling across HDMI / DisplayPort / DVI freely, unless the connected devices are HDCP-compliant. The EnjoyGadgets HDMI Switch reviewed here supports HDCP version 1.0 / 1.1 pass-through.

So, what does all this mean? It means that if your Blu-Ray, for example, works with your HDTV when they are connected directly by an HDMI cable, then they should also work with this EnjoyGadgets HDMI Switch, because the switch simply passes the HDCP encryption to your HDTV without changing anything, which is what it means by “HDCP pass-through”.

In short, if your devices all work with your HDMI cables directly, you do not have to worry about HDCP issues when using this HDMI switch.

5. Automatic and Manual HDMI Switching

This HDMI switch can choose the HD sources either automatically or allowing you to choose manually.

Automatic HDMI switching

Each time you turn on whichever source, the HDMI switch will automatically select this source. If you decide to turn on a second source, the HDMI switch will switch to this second source. If you turn on another, it’ll jump to this third device.

Auto-switching may not work when there is one or more HD sources that are “always on”, such as a HDTV recorder or a satellite network box, which you probably do not turn off that often and is always working in the background.

In that case, you will need to manually choose the HD source you want.

Manual HDMI switching

There is a “Select” button on the top of the HDMI switch that allows you to manually choose your desired HD source by pressing it once. Pressing the Select button will select the HD inputs in order.

For example, if the switch currently has Input 1 for the HDTV, pressing the Select button will select Input 2, and pressing it again will select Input 3, pressing it yet again will go back to Input 1.

If the switch currently has Input 2 for the HDTV, pressing the Select button will select Input 3, and pressing it again will select Input 1, pressing it again will select again will go back to Input 2.

So on and so forth.

In most cases you do not have to press the Select button as the auto-switching function will take care most, if not all, of the switching jobs.

Manual HDMI switching with remote control

In addition to the Select button, it would be more convenient if you could have a remote control that lets you select Input 1, 2, 3 by pressing on the remote, instead of going over to the switch and press a button on it.

Unfortunately this mini switch reviewed here does not have a remote control, but you can find an HDMI switch with remote control here. It has essentially exactly the same function and specs, except that now it has a remote control and a receiver for it. I will write a detailed comparison of these two switches later.

6. Price

You may find famously-branded HDMI switches at around $250 in a local BestBuy store, or maybe $150 if you shop around. Your intuition probably tells you this doesn’t make sense: it’s such as simple function, why does it have to cost that much? Plus, with many 42-46 inch HDTVs priced around $700 nowadays, $150 – $250 truly seems to be too much, we might as well add a couple of hundred more to buy a new HDTV.

How about…just $20?

Yes, the HDMI switch reviewed here will cost just about $20, but it will have the job done literally perfectly just as the $250 ones will.

Some part of you inside probably keeps telling you those expensive ones must have much better audio/video qualities because they cost so much more. However, in the digital world, it’s either 1 or 0: signals either get transmitted and transmitted in its 100% full quality, or it will get lost with nothing at all transmitted —- there is nothing in between.

Monster Cables has been selling HDMI cables at $50 with claimed features such as “gold-plates” or whatever materials that make up the cable, but these expensive HDMI cables will work only as well as a $2 HDMI cable. Most of the price difference is their profit.

The same applies here: the HDMI switch doesn’t modify the signals at all, HDMI signals are passed over from input port to output port untouched, and this ensures that whatever in the HDMI source will be sent to your HDTV as if the HDMI source connects to your HDTV directly. So, $20 HDMI switch will switch HDMI signals just as well as $250 ones

7. Conclusion

Pros

  • Support 3 HDMI sources;
  • HDMI v1.3b compatible;
  • HDCP v1.0/1.1 pass-through;
  • Support all HD and SD resolutions, including 1080p;
  • Support DTS/DTS-HD, Dolby Digital / Dolby Digital TrueHD, LPCM audio formats;
  • Automatic and manual switching;
  • Mini size;
  • 1-year warranty;
  • Great price.

Cons

  • Does not support the latest HDMI v1.4;
  • 3 input sources may be insufficient for some users;
  • No remote control.

If you look for an HDMI switch that can quickly switch among your 3 HDMI sources for your HDTV, this is an excellent HDMI switch at an unbeatable price. It supports virtually all HDMI devices currently on market. It supports all video resolutions and audio formats outlined in Blu-Ray standards. It’s definitely a great buy for just $20.

If you are a remote-control person, you may choose an HDMI switch with a remote control.

On the other hand, if 3D Over HDMI is a must-have feature for you, this probably isn’t the right product for you, and you may wait a little longer when the industry will eventually start adopting the new standards.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

12 Responses to “Review: EnjoyGadgets 3 Port HDMI Switch”

  1. Hello,just observed your Blog when i google something and wonder what webhosting do you use for your blog,the speed is more faster than my wordpress, i really need to know it.will back to check it out,many thanks!

    • admin says:

      Hi, it’s actually wordpress, too (version 2.9.2). Too many plugins may render wordpress slower, you could try using only the absolutely necessary plugins and removing the others.

  2. broken xbox says:

    This is an absolutely good article you have going here. The content is very informative and straight to the point. Excited to read more about your blog soon.

  3. Burl Behrman says:

    hey,Excellent blogging dude! i’m Fed up with using RSS feeds and do you use twitter?so i can follow you there:D.
    PS:Have you thought to be putting video to your blog posts to keep the people more entertained?I think it works.Sincerely, Burl Behrman

  4. EnjoyGadgets says:

    Hi Burl,

    Thanks for your kind words.

    We just had twitter set up, you can follow us here:
    http://twitter.com/EnjoyGadgets

    More will come up, it’s gonna be fun.

    And yes, we are definitely considering to include videos in articles in the future.

    Bye for now.

    Alex

  5. Yahoo Movie…

    This is really great news today….

  6. ANDREW AVEY says:

    Thank you for writing this. I am a gadget freak, however the terminology (i.e: I didn’t know that I needed more then one HDMI port when I bought my HDTV and that is used for DirecTV and, yes it is always on). I immediately wonder how I can record movies, or anything from the TV to a HD DVD or Blu Ray Player that needs an HDMI port. Would I not need two “ACTIVE” ports – one for each simultaneously? Does the HDMI selector do just that? Select one to be working with the TV at a time? That is the only part I didn’t learn from your otherwise beautifully simplistic explanation article about a gadget that I wondered if it existed until I read this. I typed, “WHY ARE FOUR HDMI PORTS ON HDTV NECESSARY?” in the Google Search Box and… I just bought my HDTV one week ago. Do you think my best option would be to return/exchange it? Not only was I disappointed by the “only one (1) HDMI port issue. I am so pleased with the beauty and clarity of HD television compared to standard definition television that I would like a 40-42 inch HDTV in place of the 24 inch HDTV 1080p ViewSonic that I purchased. The cool part of running across your article are options options which I have you to thank for them.

    In the comments from other readers I noticed that they also liked your writing style very much. Do you write elsewhere on the internet. And, isn’t the internet fabulous how in your own words you can ask a question in your own words and nail an answer and information on what you did not know.

    So, in my case, I am willing to spend more to get more size and to be sure I would have more HDMI ports. Have you heard of the brand, Proscan? They have a 40 inch, full high definition flat, wide screen. It has three (3), or four (4) HDMI ports. It is on sale at Walmart for $399. Walllmounted, the size is picture perfect for my space for a television. I have “On Demand” through DirecTV’s DVR+ via an internet connection. The DVR+ is also connected to a land line outlet for even more options. I realize I am justifying upgrading my HDTV so soon, but the difference in cost is only $65. I hope you have some insight on Proscan that you wouldn’t mind sharing with me.

    Sincerely, I look forward to see more of EnjoyGadget topics and articles. Keep up the great work(s)! Thanks again!

    Andrew Avey
    Long Beach, CA

    I can be reached by phone and email: 1-562-436-2816; 1-310-303-8695 and/or andrewavey@gmail.com.

    • EnjoyGadgets says:

      Hi Andrew,

      Thanks so much for your reply and your kind words, they are very rewarding!

      In your comments, you have some questions, and I’ll try my best to spot all of them, but if you have more or I didn’t answer them clearly, just let me know.

      Okay here we go:

      —— “I immediately wonder how I can record movies, or anything from the TV to a HD DVD or Blu Ray Player that needs an HDMI port. Would I not need two “ACTIVE” ports – one for each simultaneously? Does the HDMI selector do just that?”

      If you need to record TV programs, they’re usually recorded to your HD PVR, with the video stored on the harddisk of the HD PVR. However, recording video to a HD-DVD / Blu-Ray disk, theoretically, requires your HD-DVD / Blu-Ray player also to be able to burn disks in real time. I’m not sure if there’s a such HD-DVD / Blu-Ray player/burner that can do this, because there are two problems:

      1. For a 2 hour movie, the burner has to be running for 2 hours if it’s burning in real time, this will cause the laser head to die very fast due to long-duration burning.

      2. Although you can burn just anything very easily onto HDDVD / Blu-Ray disks as data backup, in order to let HD-DVD / Blu-Ray players to recognize the disk, the videos have to be put in very complex structures / formats according to HDDVD/Blu-Ray standards. There are Windows software to do this such as tsMuxer.

      So what does HDMI switch/switch/selector do?

      It connects your HD PVR + Blu-Ray player at the same time to your TV like this:

      (HD PVR, Blu-Ray player, HD-DVD player) —> switch —-> HDTV

      Since your HDTV has only 1 HDMI port, it cannot connect the 3 HD devices at the same time. Now with the switch, you can. When you are watching TV programming, just switch to HD PVR, when you want to watch a Blu-Ray disk, just switch to Blu-Ray player. This is what an HDMI switch do.

      —— ” I just bought my HDTV one week ago. Do you think my best option would be to return/exchange it? Not only was I disappointed by the “only one (1) HDMI port issue. I am so pleased with the beauty and clarity of HD television compared to standard definition television that I would like a 40-42 inch HDTV in place of the 24 inch HDTV 1080p ViewSonic that I purchased.”

      Was the 24inch one you recently purchased and you’re eyeing on an 40-42 incher? If so, I think $65 is totally worth the upgrade. Only when you have a large screen can you fully appreciate how great HDTV is :D . I’m using a 52 inch HDTV, and I wish I could have a 65 inch one.

      However, for me to better answer your question, could you please tell me again what exactly you need:

      1. Do you need to record TV programs to Blu-Ray disks, or
      2. Do you need to hook up multiple HD devices to your HDTV, or
      3. maybe something else?

      Have you heard of the brand, Proscan? …I hope you have some insight on Proscan that you wouldn’t mind sharing with me.

      I haven’t come cross this brand, I’m sorry I couldn’t help you on this one.

      —— “Do you write elsewhere on the internet. And, isn’t the internet fabulous how in your own words you can ask a question in your own words and nail an answer and information on what you did not know.”

      I also write in some article sites, but if you are interested in HDTV/HDMI articles, it’s easier for you to:

      1. check back our blog from time to time, or
      2. follow us on twitter (http://twitter.com/EnjoyGadgets), or
      3. add it to your RSS reader such as Google reader, so if anything new, it’ll be sent to your reader automatically.

      Yes Google is amazing at finding what you want to find. Now I don’t even remember how I used to (or able to) find information I wanted 15 years ago. People are given much more freedom nowadays to find information and do research on their own, instead of being spun and sometimes (cheated) by marketers or sellers. Which is why we, and many other business people, believe that doing sound online business today means we should be as open and informative as possible to our customers and readers, providing them with useful, unbiased, information on our website so people can find us and trust us.

      Anyway, please let me know what exactly do you need to hook up to your HDTV or HD devices, so I can better help you. Even if our products couldn’t help you, maybe I could give some suggestions what type of products might help you.

      Take care,

      Alex
      EnjoyGadgets

  7. 3-port hdmi switch with remote says:

    3 Port HDMI switch is usable most of times. I am an electrician. I know how important this is. Information provided by you is interesting. Thanks

  8. NEX-C3 says:

    Szép! Csak azt akartam válaszolni. Én alaposan szerettem a post. Kísérje figyelemmel a nagy munkát.

  9. Barry swartz says:

    Hi. My Visio tv and dish et work doesn’t “support” the switch. Any ideas. Thanks

Leave a Reply